Medical Expert Witness

$1.1M Med Mal Verdict In Sinus Surgery Suit Reversed

In 2007, Dr. Katherine Joy Shen performed a sinus surgery on Rena Berger after which she permanently lost her sense of smell and taste, and suffered other injuries too…law360, NY Court Tosses $1.1M Med Mal Verdict In Sinus Surgery Suit, Y. Peter Kang 2020


The Westchester County jury cleared Dr. Shen of negligence in surgery but came to the conclusion that she breached the standard of care by failing to inform Rena that a “dural patch” was placed inside Berger’s sinus cavity to reinforce a weakened bone. According to the jury, Rena’s injuries were caused due to this and awarded $1.13 million in damages.


The New York appellate court however, opined that there was no evidence submitted at trial that this negligence of not informing the patient of the patch “could possibly lead rational persons to the conclusion” that Shen caused Berger’s injuries. Similarly, there was no evidence presented at the trial that the patch was disturbed after the surgery.


As a result, it vacated the $1.1 million verdict in the suit, citing lack of relevant evidence.


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *